The Product
It's a battle royale of nation's: Canada's Soulstice polish in Provence versus American Apparel's polish in Malibu Green.
The Guts
Soulstice claims it's a "vegan" nail polish containing zero formaldehyde, toluene, or DBP. It's also animal testing free and PETA certified. However, AA also makes the exact same claims - without the marketing hype.
Soulstice: 1
AA: 1
Price & Packaging
Soulstice is $8.50 for 12.7 mL while AA is $9 for 15 mL making both prices quite comparable, with a slight edge to AA.
Soulstice: 1
AA: 2
Effectiveness
Both colors are quite pretty and fetching on. At first I was cautious about wearing the Soulstice shade as Provence is quite a lilac tone in the bottle. I was very pleased though that it only took 2 coats to get a nice, opaque finish with little streaking. As well, the lilac tone wasn't that bad on my NC25 skin and would be perfect for spring, or even winter I think with a cream sweater!
The AA polish was quite pigmented and required only 1 coat with a couple touch-ups on some nails to get an equally opaque coat. The Malibu Green color is GORGEOUS - so tropical and vibrant! I'm in love with this color.
Both colors wore pretty well, with no chipping for a week, but I think AA has the edge here as its full collection of shades online matches my style more. Soulstice has a lot more pastel shades whereas I prefer stronger, jewel tones.
Please excuse my crappy cuticles!
Soulstice: 1
AA: 3
Buy or ditch?
Definitely buy both!
Final Verdict
American Apparel wins over Soulstice!












